But as AI’s capabilities expand, a troubling idea has taken hold that marketing is fundamentally an engineering problem. There are AI companies that argue that with the right systems, prompts, and workflows, creativity can be automated and humans can step aside. This thinking has given rise to the notion of the “content engineer” — someone who designs the machine while AI does the marketing.
But ask any experienced CMO and they’ll tell you this is not the future of successful marketing. It’s a misunderstanding of what marketing actually is and often these statements come from people with no marketing background.
The most effective organizations are not handing the controls to AI. Instead they are treating the technology as a co-pilot while keeping humans firmly responsible for meaning, judgment, and storytelling. That distinction is not semantic. It is strategic.
The content engineer model assumes that if you can define the right inputs, you can reliably produce the right outputs. It treats marketing like a manufacturing process and creativity like a variable that can be tuned. It operates on the assumption that marketing is binary, meaning with the right input, one can enjoy a great output.
No system can fully account for how context shifts meaning, how emotion overrides logic, or how timing changes everything. No prompt can sense when a message feels opportunistic, tone-deaf, or hollow. No workflow can decide when silence is more powerful than speech. These decisions are not computational. They are human.
AI is exceptional at pattern recognition and replication. Left in control, it optimizes toward what already exists. That’s why AI-led content so often converges on the same language, the same structures, and the same conclusions. It sounds competent. It also sounds indistinguishable from everything else out there. And your audience can tell.
Marketing does not win by being quick alone but by being relevant, credible, and resonating emotionally. Those qualities don’t emerge from scale alone. They require judgment—especially the judgment to say something different, to challenge a prevailing narrative, or to slow down when everyone else is accelerating.
The promise of content engineering is efficiency. The cost is being like everyone else out there use AI slop and losing customers.
Creativity is not something you can engineer into existence. It comes from taste, lived experience, intuition, and empathy. It comes from understanding unspoken fears, internal contradictions, and cultural tension. It often comes from deliberately breaking patterns rather than reinforcing them. It comes from being human.
AI can help humans explore ideas faster. It can help them pressure-test angles, overcome blank pages, and accelerate their production. But it does not originate meaning. It recombines what already exists. Without human direction, it cannot tell the difference between what is merely plausible and what is actually true.
Context is where the human advantage becomes undeniable. Marketing exists inside moments—economic, cultural, competitive, and emotional moments that change constantly.
Humans are the ones who understand how a message will land today, not in theory. Humans are the ones who recognize when data conflicts, when feedback is incomplete, and when brand trust matters more than short-term performance.
AI can process context. Humans interpret it. Together the two can market beautifully.
Are you ready to Market like a team of 10 — even if you're a team of one? Take Skribil for a free test drive and see the power of a marketing AI platform built by marketers.